🔥Electric vs. Gas Fireplaces for Screened Porches: A Comparison

James Moylan

Wednesday, December 04, 2024

C34

When designing a screened porch, a fireplace can enhance both the aesthetic and functional value of the space, offering warmth and ambiance during cooler months. When choosing a fireplace for a screened porch, homeowners typically face the decision of whether to go with a gas or electric model.

 

Gas Fireplaces for Screened Porches

Gas fireplaces are a popular choice for outdoor spaces, including screened porches, because of their efficient heating and authentic flame appearance. They provide real flames and a more traditional ambiance, which many homeowners prefer. Gas fireplaces are typically powered by natural gas or propane and require proper venting, making installation more involved compared to electric models. They offer the advantage of higher heat output and the ability to be used for longer periods without worrying about power outages.

Advantages of Gas Fireplaces:

  1. Real Flame & Authenticity: Gas fireplaces provide a real flame, which creates a more traditional, cozy atmosphere that electric fireplaces cannot replicate.
  2. Higher Heat Output: Gas fireplaces can heat larger spaces more effectively than electric ones.
  3. Continuous Operation: As long as the gas supply is available, gas fireplaces can function continuously without needing electricity.

Drawbacks of Gas Fireplaces:

  1. Installation Complexity: Gas fireplaces require professional installation, including venting and a gas supply connection, which can make installation more expensive and time-consuming.
  2. Maintenance: Gas fireplaces require more maintenance than electric models, as they need to be cleaned and serviced regularly to ensure proper functioning.

Electric Fireplaces for Screened Porches

Electric fireplaces offer a modern, hassle-free alternative. They use electricity to generate heat and simulate the look of a flame using LED lights. Unlike gas fireplaces, electric fireplaces do not require venting, making them easier to install and more versatile for different spaces, including screened porches. However, the heat output is typically lower compared to gas models, making electric fireplaces better suited for smaller areas or milder climates.

Advantages of Electric Fireplaces:

  1. Ease of Installation: Electric fireplaces can be plugged into a standard electrical outlet and do not require any venting or professional installation.
  2. Lower Maintenance: Electric fireplaces generally require less maintenance, as they do not have moving parts or need to be cleaned as frequently.
  3. Safety: Since electric fireplaces do not involve an open flame or combustion, they are often considered safer, especially in a screened porch setting where outdoor elements might pose a risk.

Drawbacks of Electric Fireplaces:

  1. Lower Heat Output: Electric models typically provide less heat than gas fireplaces, which may not be sufficient for larger screened porches in colder climates.
  2. Lack of Real Flame: While electric fireplaces can mimic the look of a flame, they do not provide the same ambiance as a real fire.

Today, we will talk about the leading electric fireplace options.  For our feature on gas fireplaces, click here to see our blog 

Leading Electric Fireplace Brands: Simplifire, Napoleon, Uptown, and Dimplex

Simplifire

Location: Simplifire is part of the Hearth & Home Technologies group, based in Lakeville, Minnesota. The company specializes in electric fireplaces and has been operating for more than 50 years.

Best-Selling Products: Simplifire's electric fireplaces are known for their sleek designs and efficient heating. One of their most popular products is the Simplifire 48” Electric Fireplace Insert, which provides a stunning flame effect and can be mounted in various settings, including screened porches. Their products are often praised for ease of installation and stylish appearances.

5ab571deb1a54301ba5efbaebbdef356

Napoleon

fireplaceLocation: Founded in 1976 and based in Barrie, Ontario, Canada, Napoleon is one of the largest manufacturers of heating and cooling products, including fireplaces. They are well-known for their high-quality gas and electric fireplaces.

Best-Selling Products: Napoleon’s Vector Series Electric Fireplace is a standout product. It combines modern design with efficient heating capabilities, making it ideal for a screened porch. The Vector series offers an impressive flame display with customizable colors and a choice of ember bed styles. Napoleon also offers the Napoleon Alluravisionseries, which is a popular option for outdoor living spaces, providing a sleek, modern aesthetic with high output.

 

Uptown

Location: Uptown is a relatively newer player in the fireplace industry, based in the United States, known for their high-end electric fireplaces. They focus on creating innovative, contemporary designs with exceptional features.

Best-Selling Products: Uptown's Uptown Electric Fireplace Insert is one of their most popular models, offering a minimalist design with a high heat output suitable for moderate climates. The company also offers a range of contemporary-style inserts and wall-mounted electric units that are particularly suited to modern outdoor spaces like screened porches.

 

b266146bd156457b97bb09e46069a05b

 

Dimplex

Location: Founded in 1991, Dimplex is based in Ontario, Canada, and is renowned for its electric fireplace technology. They are a leading name in electric heating and fireplace solutions.

Best-Selling Products: Dimplex’s Opti-Myst® Electric Fireplace is a favorite among homeowners. Known for its realistic flame effects that mimic real smoke and fire, the Opti-Myst® creates an authentic ambiance without the need for venting or a real flame. Their Linear Wall-Mount Electric Fireplaces are also popular for modern, sleek designs that suit screened porches and other outdoor areas. Dimplex’s products are designed for easy installation and maintenance, making them perfect for those looking for a low-maintenance, efficient solution.b1927093265544bcb9d85b640edf4c85

 

Design Builders is an exterior home improvement company based in Bethesda, Maryland.  We design and build unique outdoor living spaces, specializing in screened porches, decks, and outdoor kitchens.  If you live in the DMV and would like to learn more about what we can do for you, contact us today at 301-875-2781, or fill our our form below.  We will be in touch with you shortly.  

New call-to-action